Oh, the thrill of revisiting a comedy legend on 'Saturday Night Live'—it's like a nostalgic punchline that hits just right, drawing us back to the roots of late-night laughter! But here's where it gets really exciting: Amy Poehler's return to host isn't just a reunion; it's a celebration that sparks debates on whether SNL's magic still shines as brightly. Dive in as we unpack every hilarious highlight from the October 11 episode, and you might just find yourself questioning what makes a host truly legendary.
Published under the Entertainment section, this recap covers Amy Poehler's hosting gig on 'Saturday Night Live,' featuring Role Model as the musical act.
By Kevin Slane
October 12, 2025 | 8:17 AM
About 2 minutes to read
- ...
'Saturday Night Live' made its comeback for the second show of season 51 on Saturday, October 11, welcoming back alum Amy Poehler as the host and inviting Role Model to perform.
This talented Burlington resident, who graced the 'Saturday Night Live' cast from 2001 through 2008, was taking the helm for her third time. Her initial hosting stint came in 2010, followed by another in 2015 where she shared the spotlight with her comedy partner Tina Fey.
In a perfect fit, her enduring partner in comedy appeared right away, portraying Homeland Security Secretary Kristi Noem alongside Poehler's portrayal of the fiery Attorney General Pam Bondi in the episode's political opening sketch. This setup, for those new to SNL, is a classic way the show satirizes current events through exaggerated characters, making complex politics accessible and laugh-out-loud funny.
Poehler also pointed out in her monologue that this particular broadcast coincided exactly with the 50th anniversary of the show's inaugural episode, which was helmed by the legendary George Carlin.
Advertisement:
'And mirroring George Carlin, I'm pretty buzzed right now,' she quipped with her signature wit.
She reminisced about her childhood dreams of being on the program.
'I can still picture tuning in during the '70s, cozy in my Burlington, Massachusetts home, fantasizing, 'Someday, I'll be an actress,'' Poehler shared. 'That is, until they create an AI version who's even more hilarious and game for everything, no holds barred.'
But here's the part most people miss: Fey wasn't her only friend stopping by. Her 'Parks & Recreation' co-star Aubrey Plaza snuck into a spoof of Netflix's steamy series 'The Hunting Wives,' adding layers of absurdity to the mix. Plus, both of her past 'Weekend Update' partners, Fey and Seth Meyers, teamed up with her at the desk for a playful rivalry against Colin Jost and Michael Che. These desk segments, for beginners, are SNL's news parody corner where hosts and anchors trade barbs, turning real-world headlines into comedic gold.
Advertisement:
The musical talent, Role Model—whose real name is Tucker Pillsbury and hails from Maine—even got a star cameo to elevate his act. His popular tune 'Sally, When the Wine Runs Out' often includes a celebrity playing the role of Sally on stage. For this 'SNL' rendition, Charli XCX made a quick appearance, proving how SNL keeps things fresh by blending music with unexpected guest stars.
Take a look at the clips below for standout moments from Amy Poehler's 'SNL' installment, such as her introductory monologue, the abundance of cameo appearances, and the desk visits—including Poehler's own stint—along with the guest performances.
'Saturday Night Live' Cold Open
Amy Poehler Monologue
'SNL' Weekend Update Clips
Role Model Musical Performances
Some of the Best 'SNL' Sketches
Sign up for the Today newsletter
Receive all the essential updates to kick off your day, straight to your inbox each morning.
Now, let's stir the pot a bit: Is Amy Poehler's humor still as cutting-edge as it was in her cast days, or has SNL evolved to rely too much on nostalgic cameos? And that joke about AI overtaking actors—controversial, right? Does it highlight innovation in comedy, or does it underscore fears of technology replacing human creativity? What do you think—does bringing back alums like Poehler revitalize the show, or is it time for fresher faces? Share your thoughts in the comments; I'd love to hear if you agree, disagree, or have your own wild interpretations!
